This article contains spoilers for Netflix's You season 2.
Netflix's You, ever since its season one release in 2019, has been a mega-hit across the world. Unsurprisingly, the release of season two on Boxing Day last year was no different, with many fans streaming the series in an entire day - only then, to come up with wild, at times seriously convincing theories about the show's characters and backstories.
Throughout the duration of season two, we get to know Joe's (Penn Badgley) new obsession, Love Quinn (Victoria Pedretti) a Los Angeles native who seems surprisingly down-to-earth. As the episodes progress, we learn that Love is a young widow, and through flashbacks learn of her relationship with first husband, James.
By the end of the season, we also realise that Love is fully capable of murder. In a shocking twist toward the end, viewers learn that she killed her au pair back in the day and also slits Candace's throat in an attempt to protect Joe.
Now, a popular fan theory suggests that Love is also responsible for killing her first husband too. Remember, the show tells us only that he was "sick," but we don't get any details about what he had. Love claims the doctors couldn't figure out what was wrong.
Well, of course, fans ran with this. Scroll down for the best theories about Love's first husband James, and what ~actually~ happened to him.